1---2name: channel-fit3description: >-4 Decides which marketing channels can work for a B2B SaaS company's price point, deal size, sales cycle and5 market, and how to split spend between creating demand (brand) and capturing it. Sets cost ceilings from the6 profile's own ACV, conversion rates and targets, sizes the smallest honest test per channel, checks each of 117 channels against what it needs to work, and orders the tests. Returns PLAN, MEASURE FIRST, NEEDS DECISION or8 BLOCKED. Use it when planning a year or quarter, adding a channel, or when spend is shifting without a reason.9 Not for planning one channel in depth (use linkedin-plan, reddit-plan or chatgpt-ads-check) or for setting the10 most a lead can cost in detail (use lead-value-math).11license: MIT12compatibility: >-13 Works in Claude, ChatGPT, Codex, Cursor and any agent that reads SKILL.md. Uses connected ad accounts, a CRM or14 analytics if the agent has them, otherwise exports or pasted figures. Python 3 is optional, for the unit math.15metadata:16 author: SHAKEUP17 version: "1.0.0"18 stage: decide19 plugin: strategy-messaging20 homepage: https://www.shakeuphq.com/skills/channel-fit21---22 23# Channel fit24 25Works out which channels a company can afford to win in, what each must prove in its first test, and how much goes to buyers who aren't looking yet.26 27## Purpose28 29- One job: decide the channel set, each channel's call, the order of tests and the brand and demand split for one company.30- Stage: decide. It ends in a verdict with the rule that fired.31- It never invents a benchmark: no industry cost per click, conversion rate or "typical B2B split". Every threshold comes from the profile (ACV, rates, targets) or the reader's own channel data, with its reason. A missing figure is `not available` with what would provide it.32- It doesn't build the campaign. Each channel it picks goes to that channel's skill.33 34## Use when / not35 36| Situation | Use |37| --- | --- |38| Planning the next quarter or year's channel mix | this skill |39| Deciding whether to add a channel, or which one first | this skill |40| Asked how much should go to brand and how much to demand | this skill |41| Setting the most a lead can cost and the smallest campaign budget for one channel | `lead-value-math` |42| Planning LinkedIn audiences, formats and the split inside LinkedIn | `linkedin-plan` |43| Deciding whether ChatGPT Ads fit yet | `chatgpt-ads-check` |44| Leads can't be traced to opportunities | `tracking-audit` first |45 46## Inputs47 48| Input | Required | Ways to provide, in order | If missing |49| --- | --- | --- | --- |50| Business model, ACV (or pricing), sales cycle, regions | yes | `## Company` in the profile; the reader | ask once; `BLOCKED` without ACV or pricing |51| Lead-to-opportunity and opportunity-to-won rates (or first conversion to paying customer, for product-led) | no | `## Targets`; a connected CRM; a CRM export | ceilings from a payback target only, or `not available`; coverage `partial` |52| Target cost per lead, or a CAC payback target in months | no | `## Targets`; the reader | no ceilings, so no test floors; coverage `partial` |53| Monthly budget and the pipeline target | no | `## Channels` and `## Targets`; the reader | skip the target check; coverage `partial` |54| Channel results, last 90 days: spend, leads, opportunities, customers per channel | no | connected ad accounts plus CRM; exports; pasted figures | every active channel is judged on fit only, marked `untested` |55| The facts each channel needs (a nameable account list, search demand, site traffic, video, a willing founder, communities, sales follow-up time) | no | the profile; `buying-moments` and `keyword-selection` outputs; the reader | ask the 5 that decide the most channels; the rest stay `unknown` |56| Market size and how often buyers switch (accounts that fit, years between purchases) | no | the reader | skip the in-market estimate |57 58## Profile read59 60From `company-profile.md`: `## Company` (business model, pricing, ACV, sales cycle, regions), `## Buyers` (ideal customer, buying group), `## Buying moments` (with what buyers search or ask), `## Positioning` (best fit), `## Channels` (status, budget, owner), `## Targets`, `## Accounts and data`, and every `## Learnings` entry for `channel-fit` with status `noted`, `fact` or `accepted`.61 62No profile: ask in one message for the business model, ACV or pricing, sales cycle, regions, monthly budget and the channels running now with their spend, leads and opportunities. Say that `company-profile` saves this next time.63 64## Steps65 661. **Apply learnings.** Accepted learnings for this skill override the defaults below (for example a test window the reader set). Name each one that fires.67 682. **Gather the facts.** Fill the inputs table from the profile and the reader's data. For the channel needs in `references/channels.md`, ask at most 5 questions, choosing the facts that decide the most channels first: can you name your target accounts; do buyers search for the problem or category (evidence, not belief); monthly site visitors; can sales follow up within 2 days; is the founder willing to post in their name. Map the profile's channel names to the 11: a founder's LinkedIn posts are founder-led content, and "Reddit" covers both Reddit rows unless the profile splits them.69 703. **Measurement gate.** If channels are active and no lead can be traced to an opportunity or a customer (no CRM link, no rates, no channel-level opportunities), stop at `MEASURE FIRST`: any split would be judged on form fills, which teaches each platform to find more form fillers. Hand to `tracking-audit`.71 724. **Do the unit math.** Run:73 74 ```75 python3 scripts/channel_math.py --json inputs.json76 ```77 78 When the reader gives budgets per campaign and the campaigns do different jobs (cold account campaigns and retargeting), enter each campaign as its own row with its own job. Otherwise a channel with 2 jobs is split evenly between them, and the output says so.79 80 Without Python, work it by hand and say so:81 82 | Figure | Rule | Why |83 | --- | --- | --- |84 | Value per lead | ACV x lead-to-opportunity x opportunity-to-won (or ACV x first-conversion-to-customer) | What a lead is worth in first-year revenue |85 | Ceilings | From the target cost per lead: cost per opportunity = target / lead-to-opportunity; cost per customer = target / (lead-to-opportunity x opportunity-to-won). Else from a payback target: most a customer may cost = ACV / 12 x payback months x gross margin (1 if not given), then down the funnel | The company's own limit, not a market average |86 | Implied payback | Cost per customer / (ACV / 12 x gross margin) | Shows what the target cost per lead really allows |87 | Test unit | Opportunity when lead-to-opportunity is known, else customer | Read a test on the earliest stage that tracks revenue |88 | Test floor | 5 units x the ceiling per unit, spread over the test window (90 days by default, a quarter, the period pipeline targets are set in) | With fewer than 5 units, one more or less moves the cost by 20% or more |89 | Read tests on | Opportunities when the sales cycle is longer than half the window, else closed-won | A lead from mid-window can't close inside it |90 | Opportunities needed | Pipeline target per quarter / ACV | Assumes an opportunity is valued at ACV; say so |91 | In-market estimate | Share entering the market per quarter = 1 / (years between purchases x 4) | The 95:5 logic with the reader's own cycle; always labelled an estimate |92 93 - Ceilings use the profile's `## Targets`, which are the reader's plan. If the last 90 days show a different lead-to-opportunity rate, report both and name any call that would flip on the observed rate. Don't move the ceiling unless the reader updates Targets.94 - If the implied payback is shorter than the sales cycle, say so: the target cost per lead may be too tight to scale, and that's the reader's call.95 965. **Check each channel's needs.** For each of the 11 channels in `references/channels.md`, mark every need `met`, `not met` or `unknown` with the fact behind it. Then give each channel one call (each campaign, when a channel's campaigns do different jobs), first match wins. The budget left for tests is the total budget minus funding orders 1 and 2 in step 7:97 98 | Call | Condition |99 | --- | --- |100 | `skip` | The profile marks it `never`; or a "skip when" condition holds; or a need can't be built (no account list exists for an account-based channel; nobody can answer in their own name for a community channel) |101 | `later` | Not running yet, and a need is missing that can be built, or a need is `unknown` (name it, so the reader can confirm it); or a channel it depends on isn't proven yet (Microsoft Ads waits on Google Ads within the ceiling) |102 | `fix` | Active, needs met, a demand channel with cost per unit above the ceiling: no new budget until it's back under |103 | `core` | Active, and a demand channel within the ceiling; or an active brand channel (if its reach into the target accounts isn't measured, say so and ask for it); or a channel producing opportunities whose cost isn't tracked (say so, and ask for the cost) |104 | `test` | Needs met, not yet run, and the test floor fits the budget left for tests; or no floor can be set (no ceiling), in which case the reader sets the cap and the output says the floor is `not available` |105 | `later (budget)` | Needs met but the test floor is more than the budget left for tests |106 107 A brand channel (`create`) is never cut on in-window cost per opportunity alone. Judge it on reach into the target accounts and its pipeline over 2 or more sales cycles: most buyers it reaches enter the market later. A demand channel (`capture`, `retarget`, `answer`) is judged on cost per unit against the ceiling.108 1096. **Check the model against the market.**110 - Compare opportunities needed per quarter with the opportunities the channels made in the last 90 days. The gap is what new spend or tests must find; no gap means the plan protects what already works.111 - If opportunities needed per quarter exceed the in-market estimate of accounts per quarter, the target can't come from in-market buyers alone: `NEEDS DECISION`.112 - If the spend to reach the target at the ceiling is more than the quarter's budget: `NEEDS DECISION`.113 - If the business model is product-led with no sales team, skip offers that need a sales call (demo requests, lead forms); channels must carry a self-serve offer.114 1157. **Set the split.** Fund in this order. Each amount carries the rule that set it.116 117 | Order | Fund | Up to | Why |118 | --- | --- | --- | --- |119 | 1 | Demand channels within the ceiling | Their demand limit: where search impression share lost to budget reaches 0, or where the last added spend costs more than the ceiling per unit | The cheapest pipeline that exists now. Capture can't buy more searches than buyers make |120 | 2 | Demand channels marked `fix` | Their current spend, not more | Fix before scaling a channel that costs more than a unit is worth |121 | 3 | 1 test at a time | Its test floor | 2 tests at once split the budget and blur which one worked |122 | 4 | Brand channels marked `core` or `test` | Everything left | Demand channels reach only the few buyers in market now; brand reaches the rest before they look |123 124 - Without the demand limit (no impression share or search demand data), hold demand channels at their current budget, label the limit `not available` and ask for it.125 - If step 1 uses the whole budget, the brand share is 0: write it as an open trade-off. Every future buyer would have to find the company on their own; give the amount that would fund 1 brand channel at its test floor so the reader can choose.126 - If no channel can take what is left, hold it, and name the need that would release it once confirmed.127 - If the test pool comes out of an active brand channel's budget, show the amount and offer to delay the test instead; the reader decides.128 - Report the split now and proposed: brand and demand in amounts and shares.129 1308. **Order the tests.** List the `test` channels in the order they run, 1 at a time: why this one first (the need it meets best, the buying moment it serves), its budget at the test floor, what it's read on, the success line (5 or more units within the ceiling inside the window), the stop line (fewer than 5 units, or above the ceiling at the end of the window), and the skill that plans it.131 132## Check and verdict133 134| Verdict | Condition (first match wins) |135| --- | --- |136| `BLOCKED` | No ACV or pricing, or no business model, after asking once |137| `MEASURE FIRST` | Channels are active and no lead can be traced to an opportunity or customer |138| `NEEDS DECISION` | Opportunities needed exceed the in-market estimate; or reaching the target at the ceiling costs more than the budget; or no channel passes its needs; or the reader's data conflicts with the profile on budgets or channel status |139| `PLAN` | Otherwise: every channel has a call, the split has amounts, the tests have an order |140 141Named stops:142 143- `BLOCKED`: ask for ACV or pricing and the business model.144- `MEASURE FIRST`: stop the split; hand to `tracking-audit` with what is missing.145- `NEEDS DECISION`: stop. Show the gap with its inputs and the options: widen the market (a new segment or region), raise ACV, lower or lengthen the target, raise the budget or accept a higher ceiling. Give what each option changes in the math. Write no split that pretends to reach the target.146 147`PLAN` runs through with no stop.148 149## Learn150 151Append to `## Learnings`:152 153- a test ends: a `fact` with the channel, units, cost per unit, the ceiling and the call (kept or stopped), with the source;154- the reader overrides a call or the split: a `proposal` with their reason;155- a brand channel's later effect shows up (more branded search, more self-reported mentions, a higher win rate in reached accounts): a `fact` with its source;156- a ceiling or the test window proves wrong for this company twice: a `proposal` to change it.157 158Example: `- 2026-10-24 | channel-fit | fact | Microsoft Ads test stopped: 3 opportunities at $1,400 against a $1,000 ceiling in 90 days | Why: Microsoft Ads export and CRM, 2026-Q3 | Status: noted`159 160## Output161 162```163Verdict: <PLAN | MEASURE FIRST | NEEDS DECISION | BLOCKED> · Coverage: <complete | partial (what's missing) | blocked> · Math: <script | by hand>164 165Economics166Value per lead: <n> · Ceilings (<source>): cost per lead <n>, per opportunity <n>, per customer <n> · Implied payback: <n> months167Test floor: <n> per test (<n> per month over <n> days), read on <opportunities | closed-won>168 169Channels170| Channel | Jobs | Now | Needs met / not met / unknown | Cost per unit vs ceiling | Call | Why |171(all 11, core first, skip last)172 173Target check: <n> opportunities needed per quarter · in-market estimate <n> accounts per quarter (estimate) · spend at the ceiling <n> vs budget <n> · Flags: <list or none>174 175Split176| | Now | Proposed | Rule |177| Demand | <amount, share> | <amount, share> | <order step> |178| Brand | <amount, share> | <amount, share> | <order step> |179| Test pool | | <amount> | <order step> |180 181Test order: 1. <channel>: <why first>, <budget>, read on <..>, success <..>, stop <..>, plan with <skill>182 183Not available: <figure: what would provide it>184Learnings applied: <list, or none>185```186 187Then the handoff block.188 189## Hand off190 191```handoff192skill: channel-fit193version: 1.0.0194verdict: PLAN195coverage: partial (no impression share data, so the demand limit is not available)196for: <company>, <quarter>197outputs:198 ceilings: {cost_per_lead: 250, cost_per_opportunity: 1000}199 core: [Google Ads, LinkedIn Ads]200 fix: []201 tests_in_order: [Microsoft Ads]202 later: [Google Display: confirm monthly visitors]203 skip: [Meta Ads, Reddit Ads]204 split_proposed: {demand: 14000, tests: 1667, brand: 8333}205next: [lead-value-math, linkedin-plan, microsoft-ads-b2b]206open: [add a pipeline target to run the target check]207```208 209Made-up values for illustration. `lead-value-math` takes the ceilings for each campaign; the channel skills named in `next` plan each `core` and `test` channel.210 211## Failure modes212 213| Problem | Do this |214| --- | --- |215| The reader asks for "the usual B2B split" | There isn't one this skill will give. Show the split from the funding order and the reader's own figures |216| Platform-reported conversions disagree with the CRM | Trust the CRM for opportunities and customers; note the gap |217| A channel has under 5 units in 90 days | Mark the result `small sample`; keep or stop on fit and cost per lead, and extend the test only once |218| Only 1 channel is active and it is all capture | Expected for young companies. The split shows brand at 0 with the amount 1 brand test would need |219| The sales cycle is longer than a year | Read tests on opportunities and pipeline stages; brand channels on reach into accounts. Say closed-won won't show inside any test |220| A channel's rules or availability changed | Check the channel's current documentation; `references/channels.md` notes the date its facts were checked |221 222## Influenced by223 224- Brian Balfour's Four Fits, especially channel-model fit (what a customer is worth limits the channels that can pay for them) and product-channel fit (channels don't bend to products): https://brianbalfour.com/four-fits-growth-framework225- The 95:5 rule from Professor John Dawes of the Ehrenberg-Bass Institute, written for LinkedIn's B2B Institute: most business buyers aren't in the market at any moment, so advertising mostly works by building memory for later: https://marketingscience.info/news-and-insights/advertising-effectiveness-and-the-95-5-rule-most-b2b-buyers-are-not-in-the-market-right-now and https://business.linkedin.com/advertise/resources/b2b-institute/b2b-research/trends/95-5-rule226- What we changed: ceilings and test floors come from the company's own ACV, rates and targets with no benchmarks, each of 11 channels has written needs to check, the split comes from a funding order instead of a fixed ratio, and the in-market share is estimated from the reader's own purchase cycle.