1---2name: reddit-plan3description: >-4 Plans Reddit organic and Reddit Ads together for a B2B SaaS company: finds the communities where its buyers ask5 for recommendations, compare tools and describe the problem, reads and logs each community's rules on vendors and6 self-promotion, then plans who on the team takes part (under their own names, with disclosure), what they answer,7 which communities get ads with which useful offer, and how both are measured. Refuses tactics Reddit's rules8 forbid. Returns READY, READY WITH GAPS, LISTEN ONLY, NOT A FIT or REFUSED. Use it before a company posts or9 advertises on Reddit. Not for writing the ads (use ad-variants) or for finding the third-party pages AI answers10 cite (use cited-pages).11license: MIT12compatibility: >-13 Works in Claude, ChatGPT, Codex, Cursor and any agent that reads SKILL.md. Searches Reddit through a search engine14 and reads community rules if the agent can browse; otherwise works from threads and rules the reader pastes. No15 scripts.16metadata:17 author: SHAKEUP18 version: "1.0.0"19 stage: make20 plugin: paid-media21 homepage: https://www.shakeuphq.com/skills/reddit-plan22---23 24# Reddit plan25 26Puts a company where its buyers already talk on Reddit, inside each community's rules, with organic and ads planned as one.27 28## Purpose29 30- One job: produce one Reddit plan (community map, rules ledger, participation plan, ads plan, measurement) and check it.31- Stage: make. It ends with its own check, at most 2 fix rounds.32- It never invents a thread, a community, a rule or a member count. Every thread in the plan has a link the reader can open.33- It never posts, comments, votes or launches an ad. People on the reader's team post under their own names; the reader launches ads.34- It refuses fake accounts, undisclosed employees posing as customers, vote requests, bought accounts and planted questions.35 36## Use when / not37 38| Situation | Use |39| --- | --- |40| Deciding whether and how to take part on Reddit | this skill |41| Planning Reddit Ads and wanting them to fit the communities | this skill |42| Writing the Reddit ad copy | `ad-variants`, after this skill |43| Finding which threads and pages AI answers cite for buyer prompts | `cited-pages` |44| Mining threads for the buyer's own words | `message-mining` |45| Deciding whether Reddit gets budget at all, against other channels | `channel-fit` |46 47## Inputs48 49| Input | Required | Ways to provide, in order | If missing |50| --- | --- | --- | --- |51| Category, competitors and the problem in the buyer's words | yes | `## Company`, `## Competitors`, `## Buying moments`; the reader | ask once |52| Threads where buyers talk | yes | search through a search engine if the agent can browse (patterns in `references/reddit-rules.md`); thread links the reader pastes | ask for links; without any, `NOT A FIT` can't be judged, so ask before deciding |53| Each community's rules | yes, per community | read the rules page or sidebar if the agent can browse; rules text the reader pastes | that community is `unread`: listen only |54| People who can answer (role, what they know, hours a week) | no | the reader | organic plan is listen only until someone is named |55| Reddit Ads budget per month | no | `## Channels`; the reader | no ads plan; organic only |56| Useful offers (templates, tools, guides, honest pricing) | no | the reader; the site | ads plan marks the offer `needed` |57| Max CPL | no | `lead-value-math` handoff | ads judged on engaged visits only, coverage `partial` |58| Tracked buyer prompts and their cited sources | no | `ai-answer-panel` or `cited-pages` handoff | AI citation priority skipped |59 60## Profile read61 62From `company-profile.md`: `## Company` (category, brand terms), `## Product`, `## Buyers` and `### Buying group` (to recognize a buyer in a thread), `## Buying moments` (the problem in their words), `## Competitors` (names, mention policy), `## Voice`, `## Claims and proof`, `## Channels` (Reddit's status and budget), `## Targets`, and every `## Learnings` entry for `reddit-plan` with status `noted`, `fact` or `accepted`.63 64No profile: ask in one message for the category, 2 to 4 competitors, the problem in the buyer's words, who buys, and whether there is an ads budget. Say that `company-profile` saves this next time.65 66## Steps67 681. **Apply learnings.** A community that removed a post, or one whose threads became demos, changes its tier. Name each one that fires.69 702. **Screen the request.** If it asks for anything in the "not allowed" column of `references/reddit-rules.md` (accounts posing as customers, vote requests, bought accounts, planted questions, undisclosed posting), return `REFUSED`, say which Reddit rule it breaks, and offer the compliant plan instead. Don't plan the forbidden part in any form.71 723. **Listen first.** Run the search patterns in the reference for the category, each competitor and the problem. Log every thread: link, community, date, who asked (role if stated), what they wanted, and whether a vendor already answered. Never write a thread that wasn't found.73 744. **Score the communities** with the reference's table: buyer threads in 12 months (core 12 or more, secondary 3 to 11, skip under 3), the vendor rule from the community's own rules, AI citations, and the newest buyer thread.75 765. **Write the rules ledger.** One row per community: date read, vendor rule, what the rules say in your own words with the rule numbers, links, flair or set threads, account limits. A community whose rules weren't read stays `unread`.77 786. **Plan participation** for core and secondary communities whose rules allow it:79 80 | Part | Rule |81 | --- | --- |82 | Who | named people from the team who know the problem, posting under their own accounts |83 | Disclosure | where they work, in the profile and in any reply that mentions the product |84 | What | open questions they can help with without the product; the product only when it is the most useful answer and the rules allow it; a link only when it is the best thing to share |85 | History first | take part in threads that have nothing to do with the product before the product ever comes up; respect account age or karma limits the rules set |86 | Cadence | from the hours the reader gives; a weekly listening list of threads worth answering |87 | Criticism | answer once, factually, as a named person, or don't answer |88 897. **Plan ads** if there is a budget, using the reference's settings: communities from the map (core first), conversation keywords from the threads' own words, expansion off for the test, feed and conversation split, a useful offer that works without a demo, comments answered daily for the first 2 weeks with approved replies, Pixel and Conversions API before spend, a cost cap.90 - Per-community test budget: at least 2 x max CPL, so a community can be cut on zero leads only after spending what 2 leads may cost.91 - Cut a community at that spend with 0 leads and fewer engaged visits (2 or more pages) than the others; keep and grow those with leads at or under max CPL.92 938. **Plan measurement.** Organic: buyer threads answered, threads where others name the company, visits from Reddit, and demos that say Reddit in a free-text "how did you hear about us". Ads: engaged visits from the ideal customer, leads and cost per lead against max CPL in the first weeks, cost per opportunity after the judgment window.94 959. **Feed the rest of the plan.** Questions that keep coming up go to content, ads (`ad-themes`) and sales answers.96 97## Check and verdict98 99| Check | Fails when |100| --- | --- |101| Sources | a thread without a link, or a community, rule or count without a source |102| Rules | a plan item breaks a logged rule, or covers a community whose rules are `unread` |103| Honesty | any item hides who works where, asks for votes or uses an account that isn't a real person's own |104| Offers | an ads offer that only works as a demo request |105| Budget | community tests under 2 x max CPL, or more than the budget |106| Copy | any drafted reply or ad line fails `voice-check` or `claim-check` (inline: no dashes, no profile words to avoid, every number in `## Claims and proof`) |107 108| Verdict | Condition (first match wins) |109| --- | --- |110| `REFUSED` | The request depends on a tactic Reddit's rules forbid |111| `NOT A FIT` | Under 3 buyer threads in 12 months in every community checked |112| `LISTEN ONLY` | Buyer communities exist, but every one bans vendor participation or is unread, or nobody can answer under their own name, and there is no ads budget |113| `READY WITH GAPS` | The plan stands, with open checks after 2 rounds or communities still `unread` (each named) |114| `READY` | Every check passes |115 116Named stops: `REFUSED` names the rule and offers the compliant plan. `NOT A FIT` shows the searches run and what they found. No other stops.117 118## Loop119 1201. Run the checks.1212. Fix: drop the item that breaks a rule, move an unread community to listen only, replace a demo-only offer, cut a link, raise or merge community tests to clear 2 x max CPL.1223. Check again. At most 2 rounds, then hand over with what is still open, labelled `open`.123 124## Learn125 126Append to `## Learnings` when:127 128- a moderator removes a post or warns an account: a `fact` with the community and the rule, and the ledger row updated;129- a community's threads or ads produce demos (from self-reported attribution or the CRM): a `fact`;130- a community test is cut or grown: a `fact` with spend, leads and engaged visits;131- the reader overrides a tier: a `proposal` with their reason.132 133Example: `- 2026-10-24 | reddit-plan | fact | A reply naming the product was removed under the community's rule 4 (no vendor posts outside the weekly thread) | Why: moderator message, 2026-10-12 | Status: noted`134 135## Output136 137```138Verdict: <READY | READY WITH GAPS | LISTEN ONLY | NOT A FIT | REFUSED> · Coverage: <complete | partial (what's missing)>139 140Searches run: <list> · Threads found: <n>141 142| Community | Buyer threads (12 months) | Tier | Vendor rule | Rules read on | Plan |143 144Rules ledger: <one row per community>145Participation: <who, disclosure, what, cadence, the first 4 weeks>146Ads: <communities, keywords, offer, settings, test budget per community, cut and grow rules>147Measurement: <organic; ads>148Threads to answer first: <links, with why>149Check: <each check, pass or fail> · Rounds: <n>150Open: <labelled items>151Learnings applied: <list, or none>152```153 154Then the handoff block.155 156## Hand off157 158```handoff159skill: reddit-plan160version: 1.0.0161verdict: READY162coverage: complete163for: <company> Reddit164outputs:165 participate: [<community>, <community>]166 listen_only: [<community>]167 ads_communities: [<community>]168 offer: <the useful offer>169 test_budget_per_community: 570170next: [ad-variants, ad-themes]171open: []172```173 174`ad-variants` writes the promoted posts for `ads_communities` with `offer`.175 176## Failure modes177 178| Problem | Do this |179| --- | --- |180| The agent can't browse and the reader has no thread links | Give the reader the searches to run and stop before scoring; never guess communities |181| A community's rules are in a wiki the agent can't open | Mark it `unread`; ask the reader to paste them |182| The only buyer threads are years old | Count only the last 12 months for the tier; old threads still matter for AI answers, note them |183| An employee already posted about the product without saying where they work | Recommend they edit the post to disclose it, then follow the plan |184| A thread attacks the company | One factual reply from a named person, or none; never ask others to reply or vote |185 186## Influenced by187 188- Reddit's own rules for every account, brands included: follow each community's rules, take part authentically, no content manipulation, no misleading impersonation: https://redditinc.com/policies/reddit-rules189- SHAKEUP's buyer conversation method: search Reddit through a search engine for recommendations, switching and the problem in plain words, and read before anyone posts.190- SHAKEUP's Reddit organic and Reddit Ads practice: real people under their own names, help first, ads that read like a useful post, and budget kept only where communities turn into demos.